Hiring Mistakes to Avoid When Recruiting a Remote Executive Role

While promoting from within may be easier than hiring externally, the question is whether any of your people are truly ready. A study found that a third of employees aren’t interested in taking on more responsibilities by becoming managers. Surprisingly, 39% want to stay where they are, and 51% are content with what they have.

In this case, businesses are left with only one option: hire externally. However, executive roles can be quite tricky, especially if you’re hiring remotely. 

In this article, we’ll guide you on how to avoid remote executive hiring mistakes, helping you bring on leaders who can truly lead.
‍

‍

What Makes Hiring a Remote Executive So Different?

It’s typical for businesses to bring in new employees every now and then. However, hiring someone to work remotely, especially at a leadership level, comes with its own set of challenges and is not something to take lightly. After all, these are people tasked with making big decisions and leading from a distance. 

To really understand why it’s crucial to be more critical when hiring for these roles, here are three things at stake:
‍

Influence on company culture

More than just leading or assigning tasks, your executives become ambassadors of the culture you want to build. The way they manage their teams, communicate, and even approach their own work shapes your entire environment.

Think of them as the pillars of your company. They set the tone. If you bring in someone who doesn’t align with the culture you want to promote, like supporting work-life balance, that disconnect will eventually ripple through the rest of your team.
‍

Decision-making from afar

This is another crucial reason why hiring remote executives needs to be done right. They’re responsible for making decisions, and those choices can be critical, especially in urgent situations. Otherwise, you risk endless, unnecessary, and time-consuming back-and-forth, which no business owner wants. 

What you need are remote leaders who know what they’re doing and can confidently make, support, and stand by their decisions.
‍

Direct impact on team performance

The people at the top influence how things are done; that much is true! But leadership also has a direct impact on retention! In fact, 50% leave their jobs because of bad managers! So, you can imagine that a poor fit at the executive level can easily push your best people out the door.

That’s why hiring an executive who knows how to lead remote teams is so important. And it’s good to keep in mind that being a great leader in the office doesn’t automatically translate to being a great leader remotely.

‍

Common Remote Executive Hiring Mistakes You Don’t Want to Make

Many businesses still make the same hiring mistakes again and again. And when you’re building a remote team, those slip-ups can lead to bigger problems.

Take a look at some of the most common mistakes in remote executive hiring:
‍

1. Relying too heavily on credentials, not outcomes

It’s so easy to get impressed by a long list of degrees or big-name companies on someone’s resume. But titles and credentials don’t always tell you how someone actually performs on the job.

When hiring remote leaders, focus on outcomes. Ask questions about what they’ve built, how they’ve handled challenges, and how they made a difference. This will tell you more about what they can bring to the table should they work for you.
‍

2. Overlooking remote leadership experience

Unlike in an office, where you can call a quick meeting, read the room, or monitor progress face-to-face, remote leadership requires a completely different approach. You can’t just walk into someone’s home office. Schedules need to align, and even emails or direct messages don’t always capture the tone or intent you want them to. Details can easily get lost along the way, and that’s a real challenge.

This is why you need a leader with proven experience managing remote teams. Someone who understands what it takes to make distributed teams work effectively.
‍

3. Skipping cultural alignment interviews

Cultural fit is often misunderstood as simply hiring someone who fits in, and that’s far from what you actually need. In a remote setup, cultural fit is about whether a leader can align with and reinforce the processes, values, and expectations that drive your business forward.

That’s why it’s better to address this early. Don’t wait until onboarding to talk about culture! Bring it up during the interview stage to get a clear sense of whether the candidate can truly lead your team remotely and uphold the culture you want to build.
‍

4. Ignoring time zone logistics and async work fit

When you’re working with both a local and remote team, there’s a sweet spot for collaboration that you need to maintain. With differences in time zones and locations, alignment is key to making work run seamlessly. The goal is to ensure that progress continues even when one side of the team has signed off for the day.

Yes, distributed teams can be a challenge, as often said. Still, with a leader who can establish the right processes, clear communication, and proper planning in place, the back-and-forth becomes much easier to manage.
‍

5. Failing to test communication style and clarity

It’s not enough to ask if someone’s a “good communicator.” You need to see how they communicate. Do they write clear emails? Can they explain their ideas simply? Are they good at listening and responding thoughtfully?

From the very first interaction, pay attention to these details. The way a candidate communicates with you is often the same way they’ll communicate with your team. And since communication is the backbone of remote leadership, this is something you can’t afford to overlook.

‍

What You Should Be Doing Instead

Now that you know what mistakes to avoid, let’s shift to what you should be doing when hiring remote leaders.

Here’s how to set yourself up for success right from the start:
‍

Align the role with clear expectations from the start

Before you even post the job, make sure you’re crystal clear on what you want this person to do. For example:

• What will they own?
• How will success be measured?
• What will their first 90 days look like?

Remote executive roles don’t work well with vague job descriptions. In fact, no remote role does. The more specific you are about responsibilities and goals, the more likely you’ll attract the right kind of leader, not just someone who looks good on paper.
‍

Prioritize communication over charisma

Communication over charisma any day!

A potential hire might give off a great vibe and shine in interviews because of their personality, but that doesn’t always translate into actual capability. Don’t get us wrong! Charisma is a plus, and you can definitely take note of it. However, when it comes to remote leadership, the ability to communicate clearly takes precedence.

Candidates who listen well, explain their ideas effectively, and adapt their communication across different channels show the strongest potential to lead. After all, great leaders don’t need to be the loudest but the clearest.
‍

Assess remote leadership in action

It’s important to dig deeper into your potential hire’s experience in leading remote or distributed teams. Go beyond the resume and ask questions like:

• Can you share an example of how you managed a team across different time zones?
• What tools or systems have you used to keep communication clear and efficient in a remote setup?
• How do you handle performance management when you can’t see your team face-to-face?

You can also ask situational questions, give them a scenario, and evaluate how they would approach it. While it may not give you the full picture, it offers valuable insight into their thought process and whether it aligns with how you want your team to be led.
‍

Think long-term culture fit, not just short-term impact

Steer clear of band-aid solutions! Instead, look for leaders who can grow with your business. Focus on the lasting impact their skills and capabilities can bring, rather than quick fixes.

Also, consider whether they’re a cultural fit and if they align with what your company truly stands for. These areas matter most when hiring a remote executive who’s in it for the long run.
‍

Involve your existing team early and often

As much as you want a capable leader to guide your team, your team wants the same. That’s why it’s never over the top to include them in the process. 

Consider inviting team members to sit in on interviews or even contribute to the best questions to ask for any potential leader.

By doing this, you gain valuable perspective and may even spot potential red flags early on. Plus, it gives your team a sense of involvement, which makes it easier for them to embrace and trust a new leader once they’re on board.
‍

Check references with a remote focus

When you call references, don’t just ask the usual questions about work ethic or results. Ask: 

• How did they lead remotely?
• Did they communicate clearly? 
• Were they responsive and organized? 
• How did they keep their team aligned?

Ensure your potential hire’s experience supports your aim: finding a remote executive fit to lead your remote team.
‍

Look for adaptability and tech savviness

Since remote operations rely heavily on tools and platforms, openness to change is a must. So, whether it’s adopting new techniques or learning new software, you need to know if your potential hire is adaptable and willing to adjust.
‍

Plan a thoughtful, multi-step interview process

No single quick call will show you how a candidate actually works.  So, take your time with a multi-step process that lets you really get to know your candidate.

You can also mix things up. Conduct video calls, give them a small assignment, and even include informal chats with other team members. This helps you see their different sides and ensures they’re truly the right fit.

‍

Set Up Your Remote Executive for Success

Unsure how to navigate remote hiring for leadership roles? MultiplyMii is here to guide you.

We specialize in remote staffing and have spent over a decade helping businesses worldwide build high-performing teams with top Filipino talent. From sourcing and vetting to compliance and onboarding, our process goes beyond recruitment. With our expertise, avoid costly executive hiring mistakes and gain leaders who can truly drive remote success.

Ready to see how remote staffing done right can transform your team? Schedule a free, no-obligation consultation today.

‍